Oklahoma, 1984

No, this is not about the many things that happened in our state over thirty years ago such as the Tulsa floods or the space shuttle Discovery landing in Altus.  This is about the movement towards the Orwellian world described in the famous novel.

Will Rogers

One of the evils of democracy is you have to put up with the man you elect whether you want him or not.

Oklahoma Representative Dan Fisher introduced “emergency legislation” targeting funding for Advanced Placement courses on American History.  His reason: the course fails to teach “American exceptionalism.”  Evidently, historical facts get in the way of fantasy.  George Orwell dealt with this in his novel, with the protagonist Winston Smith responsible for revising history to suit current political needs.

Fisher’s attempt to change the curriculum that, according to him, characterizes America as “a nation of oppressors and exploiters” is curious, especially in Oklahoma.  It is true that many natives like to trace their arrival to the land run of 1889.   This ignores the earlier arrival of many Oklahoma natives, some willingly and others not.  I suppose that eliminating slavery and genocide from U.S. history would provide a more “exceptional” image of the nation, but it would also gloss over many struggles that have served to reinforce American exceptionalism.

Oklahoma faces many problems.  I remain surprised that our elected representative choose history and current fashion to address while ignoring the ongoing drought, the lack of jobs paying livable wages, the deterioration of education and infrastructure, and the fact that Oklahoma is now the most seismically active region in the United States.  I suspect much of this would surprise and trouble our forefathers, including those that arrived after 1889.

Another way of looking at this ill-conceived effort is its potential impact on both the students who take the test and on the state budget.  The course itself was developed by a private group, the College Board, an organization that is older than the state of Oklahoma.  In addition to the SAT exams, known and feared by high school students nationwide, the Advanced Placement courses are intended to help prepare high school students for college-level work.  Further, students who pass the exams receive college credit at many universities and the courses are de facto requirements for admission to many of the most selective universities in the country.  Abandoning these widely accepted and utilized courses would also impose costs on the state.  Developing a substitute would cost the state of Oklahoma, already known for the extreme cuts to its education budget in recent years, an estimated $4 million dollars that could be used for more useful purposes.

Although Fisher withdrew the bill and offered to rewrite it,  his effort to call for a “review” of the College Board’s curriculum that is accepted nationwide is still on the table.  I doubt his efforts to fight “progressive initiatives” will end here.  Personally, I prefer a progressive approach to the alternative, regressive approach.  Please, Mr. Fisher, focus on the issues that can improve our quality of life here in Oklahoma rather than seeking to undermine the efforts of our underpaid educators

© Hi-7 Ranch 2002-2018