Open Letter to Markwayne Mullins

Will Rogers

The thing about my jokes is they don’t hurt anybody.  You can take ‘em or leave ‘em.  You know what I mean.  You know, you say, well they’re funny or they’re terrible, or they’re good or what ever it is, but they don’t do any harm.  You can just pass them by.  But with Congress, every time the make a joke it’s a law.  And every time they make a law it’s a joke.

Markwayne Mullins, our esteemed congressman and local plumber, recently held a series of townhall meetings throughout the district.  He was accosted for his approach to gutting the Affordable Care Act and depriving thousands of his constituents of health care.  After I wrote to him asking for his justification for his stance, he responded with this canned piece that answered none of my questions.

Mullins:

"This week, we have released the American Health Care Act that will repeal the most harmful elements of Obamacare and offer relief to all those who are suffering. Our plan…

• lowers the cost of health care

• places patients back in control

• ends the individual mandate that infringes on our freedom by forcing people to purchase insurance

• provides additional funding for states that haven't expanded Medicaid (like Oklahoma) to support priorities like rural hospitals and communities 

• returns power to the states by ending hospital cuts in states that did not expand Medicaid (like Oklahoma)

• covers pre-existing conditions

• provides tax credits that are aged-based – not income–based

• blocks federal funds from going to abortion providers like Planned Parenthood

• offers more choices for you to choose what is best for you and your family.

The Affordable Care Act, better known as Obamacare, was a whopping 2,700 pages long. Our bill is only 123 pages long.  I’m sure you have questions or are looking for specifics.  Head over to readthebill.gop to find out more. “

Efforts to reach his office went unanswered, so I composed the following letter to him and shared it wtih newspapers in the area.

--------

Congressman Mullin, 

Thank you for your stock reply to my concerns about your support for gutting the healthcare for Oklahomans (HR708).  Your support for the current proposal, which will result in almost 40,000 of your constituents losing recently acquired healthcare insurance continues to bother me.  

Moreover, your latest newsletter contains several factual errors and misrepresentations.

The claim that this bill will not reduce costs, but instead will actually increase the cost of health care by removing many people from the healthcare pool, leaving only the least profitable customers to pay an increasing amount for their insurance.

I am not sure what you mean by putting "patients back in control," but assume that the increasing costs to consumers (and profits to insurance companies) will increase the number of plans available, justifying this claim.

Claiming the individual mandate "infringes our freedom" is an interesting justification.  However, mandates in general (auto insurance, paying taxes, etc.) seem to be necessary to promote the general welfare of the country.  Removing them weakens the strength of the nation.

The claim of "additional funding" for the state of Oklahoma does not ring true.  Taking funds away from other states while reducing the overall resources to pay for this, simple math tells me that this plan will lower the amounts for ALL states and threatening the health of rural hospitals.

The tax credits you tout appear to be income based, with the largest benefit going to the most affluent consumers. It also allows an increase of almost 70% to the costs for older consumers, the subject I first contacted you about.

Your claims on Planned parenthood are a bit off as well.  Since the organization receives no government funds for abortions, your plan to defund them is primarily a way to restrict pre- and post-natal healthcare for millions of women who rely on them for service.  Further, your efforts to impose your religious views on the general public are at odds with the precepts of the U.S. constitution which guarantees no imposition of religion by the government.

The two choices this bill ensures are to either pay more for insurance or do without in order to pay for rent, utilities, and food.

Trumpeting the length of the bill, something that has no relevance to the utility of it, again is an attempt to mislead the public with a method more commonly known as a "bait-and-switch."  While the ACA, at 2,700 pages, is likely bloated with excessive detail, the AHCA at 123 pages is probably appropriate.  Let me use an analogy you will understand:  It takes me less time to tear out the old plumbing that to install the new.  This does not mean that I would prefer the removal to the installation.

In all, while I expect you to support this bill despite the negative consequences to your constituents, it is disappointing that you are unwilling to either explain its impacts clearly or to provide any substantive response to constituent queries.

Sincerely, 

Russell J. Hanks

© Hi-7 Ranch 2002-2018