by St. Alfonzo
The recent tendency in US foreign policy has been one of isolation and unilateralism, as if bullying everyone could make the United States more secure. In spite of this concerted and conscious effort to isolate the United States from the rest of the world while imposing the export of our corporate output, the future security and stability of America depends on embracing it strongly and cooperating with a range of partners on a variety of interests.
Logically, dear reader, you might expect a studied expounding of the values of increasing US cooperation with international law, further support of international institutions and a fuzzy green/socialist "We Are The World" kind of philosophy.
Instead, allow me to propose something radically different, and something that does not seem to have been on the minds of Americans for quite some time.
LET'S EXPAND!!
In the future I hope to expand on this notion, but for the time being let me just throw out the brief outline of what I am thinking. As noted in the intro to this website, one of the reasons for establishing it was to encourage discussion. With that in mind, I invite you to proceed.
The United States of America, 228 years old this year, was founded as a series of colonies sent by European monarchs to exploit the "New World." Leaving aside the questionable characterization of a previously settled continent as new, the terms did become entrenched in the psyche of our nation and form one of the bases of our current political messianic complex. After throwing off the yoke of our colonial masters, who were after all only ourselves and not some "outsiders," we marched towards our "Manifest Destiny," expanding to every corner of our new continent, limited only by the Spanish/Mexican border to the south and the British/French/Canadian holdouts to the north. Over time, Americans came to believe that the country was on a mission to educate the world so that democracy and the free market way of life could flourish everywhere.
In spite of the current bias towards dominance of force rather than force of moral conviction, one of the primary goals of US foreign policy today remains the spread of democracy, liberalization of economies and defense of human rights, even as questions about our definitions of these amorphous concepts arise.
Put it to the test. You want American values around the world, invite the world in.
Historically, the U.S. has been expansionist. Basically, this period ended at the west coast, with the exception of Hawaii and Alaska. Since then, we have inherited a few post-colonial possessions. While apparently permanent, no move has been made to settle their status as somewhere between colonies or protectorates and full membership in the greater community of the "United States."
An opportunity existed and was passed with the application of the Dominican Republic for statehood in the late 1800’s. Imagine the difference if, beginning with that half of La Isla Hispaniola, the United states had looked further than the continental borders for membership. If President Grant had signed the bill, we might have approached new states with a more open mind. I think it is time to revisit the inhibition on new states.
Please do not misunderstand. I am not suggesting new wars of conquest to annex territory. We live in a world that is heavily influenced by the concept of “rule of law.” What I suggest is to encourage those countries that see a benefit to follow their own guidelines and “apply for membership.” Even when nations begin applying for admittance to the Union, though, we will have domestic problems, politically. The current polarization in our polity creates a situation much like that leading up to the Civil War. Any new states admitted would have to support the current political alignments whether or not they make sense, otherwise the entrenched interests in the “Blue-Red” division of America would see their perceived dominance slip away. Personally, I believe that the more varieties of representation that we have would improve the quality of decision-making. Let us leave the domestic political ramifications aside for another day and jump into the issue of where the new states would come from.
My examples, which are meant to be neither suggestions or exhaustive lists, fall into two categories. First are a number of small nations with limited viability on their own and otherwise strong ties to the U.S. In proximity, the Caribbean islands are a good example. These small islands with populations small in comparison would provide an infrastructure already in place, a population that would not be noticed in the greater population of America and enormous economic potential. Maybe individually they would be too small, but what about a Caribbean state including all the islands that chose to join. Following the island theme, how about Cape Verde, nine islands in the middle of the Atlantic. The advantage there is location and a population that has been tied strongly to the United States for centuries.
Along the same line, Guyana would be an interesting choice. A country the size of Great Britain or Idaho, Guyana has fabulous resources and great potential. It also has a population of less than one million persons and strong ties to the United States. It would also expand the reach of the U.S. directly into South America.
The theme here is to expand the geographic reach of the United States, include more in the benefits that we all agree that we enjoy, and ensure the expansion of human rights, democracy and rule of law. The costs seem to me to be relatively small in exchange for some outsized benefits.
On the other end of the spectrum would be nations that offer specific advantages. Close societal ties, special geographic position and “absorbability” should be the considerations here. The only limits should be the last: any nation with a population that could tax the capability of our own infrastructure to absorb and provide would, without a doubt, be problematic. Obviously, the population of India or China would be too large. My initial thoughts would be that any population of 100 million or more would be too difficult. Probably many nations of 50 million would be difficult, but a case by case determination would be the preference.
What do you think? Anyone else tired of a flag with only fifty stars? Let’s do something about it.
