by Abu Ta'ir al-Mahdi
The recent legacy of the Global War on Terror (GWOT in government terms) seems to be the acceptance of torture as acceptable in combatting to terror. (Eavesdropping on Americans seems to be in vogue as well and I may deal with this in a future posting.)
In this endeavor, it seems that the Department of State and the U.S Military both protested but were overruled by “rogue” elements of the Justice Department, Pentagon civilians and possibly by the Secretary of Defense himself.
Early memos, written as early as 2001, claimed that the Geneva Convention did not apply to Afghanistan since it was a “failed state. “ According to the memos, by denying prisoners’ rights, harsh interrogations would not violate international humanitarian laws. It was also hoped that the declaration would trump U.S. law and prevent Americans from being prosecuted for war crimes, limiting any legal recourse by detainees held incommunicado in various locations. Another troubling aspect of this innovative use of legal gymnastics was the practice of returning detainees to countries widely criticized for condoning torture, thereby ensuring Americans’ complicity in actions taken by these other countries.
In December, 2002, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld signed a memo specifically authorizing forced nudity, use of dogs, deprivation of light and sound stimulation, isolation for thirty days, use of head hoods, removal of religious items, forced hair-shaving and twenty-hour interrogation sessions. The memo was for Guantanamo, but the techniques sound like the photos from Abu Ghraib in Iraq.
The Department of State warned in January, 2002, that if the United States failed to uphold the Geneva Conventions, it could provoke foreign prosecutors to investigate U.S. officials and troops. Had the U.S. Government applied the Conventions, it would have demonstrated that the U.S. continued to base its policies on international legal obligations instead of policy preferences.
The military was apparently equally concerned and legal experts within the military raised the alarm that ignoring the Geneva Conventions would create problems with our own operations. Arguing that legally and morally, the decision would be unjustified, they also warned that others would not have to comply when facing our troops, putting them in even greater danger.
The next misstep came when the “legal experts” attempted to apply the already shaky legal grounding for the use of torture in the GWOT and Afghanistan to Iraq. Hardly a failed state, at least until after the U.S. invasion, there is no doubt that the Geneva Conventions should have applied in this situation, but the same techniques were applied to Iraq. The result is obvious: the United States is enmeshed in two conflicts with little hope for an early solution. Afghan control of its nation is largely limited to the capital city of Kabul while the hinterlands have been abandoned by a “coalition force” too small for its role. Control of these prime smuggling and drug producing regions has been ceded largely to the same warlords plaguing the country since the Soviet invasion and production of heroin is at an all time high.
In Iraq, a similar story is playing out. While we trumpet the “successes” of the American occupation of the country, bombings and murders continue unabated. According to CNN recently, since the inauguration of our “elected” government, the number of attacks nationwide has gone from an average of 45 to 70 daily. We contest the same ground repeatedly, withdrawing to our “green zones” at the end of each battle and allowing the forces fighting against our occupation to regroup. The imposed political processes have done little to ameliorate the problem, imposing Shi’a and Kurd rule on the Sunni minority with no effort to address their very real concerns about marginalization. U.S. casualties are over two thousand with no sign of ending, and this ignores the tens of thousands that have been wounded and the uncounted - but by some estimates over a hundred thousand - Iraqi civilian and security casualties. None of this is intended to slight our troops in Iraq, mostly young people that had no better life options and middle aged National Guardsmen who signed up to augment their survival wages in the “global economy.”
Do we wonder why “the world hates Americans?” Our moral authority and reputation of supporting social progress built since the early twentieth century has evaporated. The world increasingly views the United States as the purveyor of oppression and our commitments to “democracy, liberty and freedom” look increasingly doubtful when we do not even defend the civil liberties of our own citizens. But forget the world for the moment, where is our own liberty headed to?
Dean Acheson once said that security declines as the security machinery expands. “The machinery calls for a secret police to protect us from unsuitable servants in sensitive positions. Then it broadens rapidly and permeates non sensitive areas, and finally business and industry. A secret-police system first unsettles, then desiccates, then calcifies a free society.” Our founding fathers understood this; we need to understand as well.
