Jim Kuhnhenn of the Associated Press got several things wrong in his “fact check” of President Obama’s speech to the nation on his job plan and the opposition to it in both the Senate and the House of Representatives. Overall, he highlighted the points of difference, but made several assumptions and ignored historical precedence in dismissing Obama’s assertions and allowing unsupported claims from Republicans and the business community.
OBAMA: "If it turns out that there are Republicans who are opposed to this bill, they need to explain to me, but more importantly to their constituencies and the American people, why they're opposed, and what would they do."
THE FACTS: Kuhnhenn cited a Sept. 16 memorandum from House Speaker John Boehner to House Republicans suggesting they could find common ground with Obama on, among other things, the extension of certain business tax breaks, incentives for hiring veterans, and job training measures in connection with unemployment insurance.
Business tax breaks are an obvious priority for Republicans. Unfortunately, historical data suggest they do no produce new jobs. And while hiring veterans is a noble gesture, there are already incentives in place for this. Job training measures could prove to be useful, but this program has been going on since the eighties when President Reagan initiated the Job Training Partnership Act. Unless something new is added, it is a tired old policy of limited potential. Unless jobs are available, training is futile.
Kuhnhenn also said Republicans objected to new spending on public works programs, suggesting instead that Congress and the president work out those priorities in a highway spending bill. This is one thing that was proven to work in the Great Depression of the thirties when President Roosevelt created the WPA.
And Republicans opposed additional spending to prevent layoffs of teachers, police officers and other public workers. Those layoffs have to potential to increase unemployment, depress the economy and cripple the chances for America’s economy to rebound by removing security and educational opportunities across the nation.
In other words, instead of investing in the future needs of American infrastructure, security and education, Republicans would prefer to starve not only this generation, but remove opportunities for our children and grandchildren.
OBAMA: "Every idea that we've put forward are ones that traditionally have been supported by Democrats and Republicans alike."
THE FACTS: Republicans have not traditionally opposed raising taxes, as Kuhnhenn claims. It is a matter of record that President Reagan raised taxes several times during his two terms in office when confronted with a difficult financial situation. Republicans traditionally have been on the side of fiscal common sense, something that has disappeared since the turn of the century.
OBAMA: "The answer we're getting right now is: Well, we're going to roll back all these Obama regulations... Does anybody really think that that is going to create jobs right now and meet the challenges of a global economy?"
THE FACTS: The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the mouthpiece for big business, last month called on Obama to ease regulations on businesses. It specifically called for streamlining environmental reviews on major construction projects and to delay the issuance of some potentially burdensome regulations until the economy and employment have improved. The Chamber did not indicate how many jobs such regulatory changes could create, but it said: "Immediate regulatory relief is required in order to begin moving $1 trillion-$2 trillion in accumulated private capital off of the sidelines and into business expansion."
While streamlining business regulations is a great idea, given the explosion of complex and unhelpful detail in the Federal Register in the past thirty years, the suggestion the Chamber makes is aimed at ensuring that business continues to profit from removing costs from their books to the public domain. By creating these externalities, we have arrived at our current quandary where businesses profit from creating environmental problems, then expect the government to pay for remediation, yet another form of business bailout that the majority of Americans is against.
Further, the accumulated private capital cited by the Chamber will “move off the sidelines” only when demand for products increases. The only question is whether America will create jobs to increase demand domestically or will stay on the sidelines as other countries create those jobs so we can take a back seat to international demand.
OBAMA: "We can either keep taxes exactly as they are for millionaires and billionaires, with loopholes that lead them to have lower tax rates, in some cases, than plumbers and teachers, or we can put teachers and construction workers and veterans back on the job."
THE FACTS: Kuhnhenn got this one basically correct, but ignored a couple of details. He cited IRS statistics that showed for 2009, 1,470 households filed tax returns with incomes above $1 million yet paid no federal income tax. On average, taxpayers who made $1 million or more paid 24.4 percent of their income in federal income taxes; those making $100,000 to $125,000 paid 9.9 percent; those making $50,000 to $60,000 paid 6.3 percent. When payroll taxes are factored in, the rate for workers in the lowest bracket climbs. Also, at the top of the millionaire scale, those households tend to earn less income than interest and dividends. When the impact of these non-wage earnings are included, many more “millionaires” pay much lower taxes.
Instead of providing a balanced “fact check,” Kuhnhenn has offered what passes for politically correct journalism today. Walter Cronkite would spin in his grave. Giving opposing viewpoints a voice does not necessarily provide accurate information. By allowing the fringes of opposing political camps to air their opinions as if they were supported by facts does not help the general public gain a better understanding of the situation. Read carefully, and understand who has an interest in manipulating the debate. News outlets evidently do not have time to help.
Kuhnhenn, Jim. “Fact Check: Obama claims miss some evidence.” http://news.yahoo.com/fact-check-obama-claims-miss-evidence-201911584.html, Yahoo! News, Oct. 6, 2011.
