Our family just spent another afternoon at the local recreation center where our youngest son is playing his first football season. As we watched, I began thinking about where my family is now and where it might be headed. As a federal worker, headed towards retirement in the next few years, we are typical in many ways. Although I just returned from an assignment to Baghdad, our family – including a stay-at-home spouse, two pre-teen children and a live-in adult son – live on a tree-lined street in a (usually) quiet neighborhood of Baltimore, Maryland. Our days are spent commuting, running the kids to their after-school activities, and otherwise making the best of our fairly comfortable situation. Despite the ranting about the evils of public employees, we are not well-off. We are in pretty good shape though, bringing in roughly twice the American average median income of $50,000 annually. While we are not in the top one percent of American households, we are actually far better off than many.
The economic meltdown did not have a grave impact on our household, but it did point out the fact that our children are not going to have the same opportunities that we did. While the turbulence brought many stresses, the biggest drag on our family’s finances is the house we purchased before the bubble: a modest, older, four-bedroom in an established community. Our family is not alone in confronting this challenge and many others face the same situation with far worse numbers. Our house is barely “underwater,” not so much that we could not sell, but without a market to sell it in, it is worthless.
So we watched with anticipation President Obama’s changes to the Home Affordable Refinance Program, looking for ways that it might help us manage our situation better. And, in fact, it might prove useful in our situation. While it is a step in the right direction, more needs to be done. Previously, the emergency programs helped Americans in default, a small percentage of 132 million homeowners, most of whom remain current on their houses despite the 16.2 million houses with negative equity.
While the government managed to spend almost a trillion dollars to help out the banks, it did nothing to help the consumers (you and me) and then watched in confusion as consumer demand did not buoy the economic recovery. And emergency programs to prevent foreclosures did nothing to help the majority, instead focusing on a small number of mortgages with a too little-too late approach. A better solution is to refinance many homes, eliminating perhaps 10% of mortgage debt from homeowners’ (consumers’) balance sheets, faciliting the banks’ write-down of the debt, and overseeing the subsequent revival of the housing market. This program has the added benefit of strengthening consumer confidence and raising demand to support an expanding economy.
When the obligation to pay the mortgage is in conflict with the obligation to one’s family and its long-term well-being, it is hard to justify individually supporting the profligate lifestyle of the top bankers, fatuous arguments about responsibility notwithstanding.
