by St. Alfonzo
First, answer a yes or no question: Do you think access to health care should be limited to those privileged enough to deserve it? If you answered yes, I have little to say to you, although I would be happy to engage that conversation as well. If you said no, then you likely agree that any American should be able to receive treatment based on needs rather than means. Read on.
As promised, or at least alluded to, in a previous post, it seems to be time to look at health care issues in the United States. Driven by the current contentious engagement on proposed changes to our system, the topic seems to be constantly in the news. First, a little history.
Our founding fathers were clear in the Declaration of Independence that “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” were key to the success of the new United States of America. The intent here seems to have been the provision of opportunities to the newly minted citizens to excel where they deemed fit while being protected from undue tribulations from any source of oppression.
I would like to look in to this for a moment. It seems to me that of these terms, “Life” would include good health, private opportunities, education, and security. “Liberty” also includes security as well as freedoms; both freedom to do things and freedom from oppression. The least well defined—and the one said to have been drafted last—is the “Pursuit of Happiness.” Still, it would seem to be obvious that this would also include certain freedoms, access to opportunities, education, and health. Hence, the founding fathers framed the Declaration of Independence to include health care for all, making it a valid topic for political debate.
Based on the documents left behind by Thomas Jefferson, Adams, Madison, Hamilton, John Jay, Benjamin Franklin and others, it is clear that defending the rights of the individual were carefully balanced with the tyranny of the majority. The other concern was the expected development of special interests, a state of affairs viewed as most threatening to the continued health of the United States.
I would like to suggest that everyone in the United States should have access to health care. Is this so radical? I don’t think so, and I have heard no one argue that health care should not be available to all. Many dispute the method to make this happen, but many of the ones most vocally opposed are typified by the people turning out for the so-called town hall meetings across the U.S. this August.
You know that in some cases it just doesn’t make sense to try to engage in dialog with people. They will not listen and it just irritates those, both for and against, that do have comments to offer. Congressman Barney Frank actually had it right when he asked one woman “what planet do you spend most of your time on.” When faced with irrational and emotional attacks not based on any objective sense of reality, why bother. The talk about the Republican amendment to the bill that Republicans are criticizing as “killing you grandparents” is typical of the lack of sense in the issue. Sorry for the digression.
Back to the premise, that everyone should have access to health care. If we can agree to this, then the problem becomes one of a method to ensure this. If I recall the complaints about our health care system originating some twenty years ago with the ascendancy of HMOs, vast numbers of people were complaining that their provider decided whether they needed care or not. Sounds like the same companies now that are complaining about a system to allow everyone access. The insurance companies, whether traditional or HMO, make their money by limiting health care to their clients. This is not in dispute, it is just a fact of the way businesses work. They also remove the incentive from their customers to manage their own health care by creating multi-tiered fee systems based on the carrier, the provider, and the hospital. I have tried to find out how much a procedure might cost, and the hospital refuses to provide a price. In fact the price is different depending on which, if any, coverage the patient might have.
The knee-jerk response is that anyone without adequate coverage can always “go to the emergency room.” Is this where you need to go for a minor fever that Motrin off the shelf would cure? Sure seems like a waste of resources to me.
My main point here is that decisions about access to health care should not ultimately reside in the domain of a for-profit business. Is that how we decide who gets “national security?” Okay, some for-profit businesses do have more say in this field than our own national leadership, but it is not the way the system is designed. How about education? Again, despite privatization efforts, the basic concept of education for all is still defended. There are some things that are uniquely government, others that are uniquely private, and still others that are somewhere in between. Whether police protection, public utilities, or public transit, there are variations in provision across our nation.
It seems that either a public option, or even the coop compromise, should be allowed in the health care system. The argument against it is the same argument against Social Security and the current Medicare system. Ask you grandparents, would they want to give up Medicare? If they were in agreement on this, then the public option could be put to rest. But if Medicare and Social Security basically serve the function they were designed for, the public option is valid. Further, you must ask yourself why the for-profit businesses are so dead set against a public option? If they cannot compete, they should go out of business. Isn’t this the basic tenet of capitalism?
Yet another reason to consider the public option for health care, or at least an option not subsidized by our employers, is globalization. While many economists will try to let you know about the complexities of economic systems and sway you with pretty arguments supported by a whole lot of numbers, globalization is actually pretty simple. Any business needs a product and customers to survive. In the production of its goods, the business will consider three basic categories of costs: infrastructure, consumable, and labor. If all the businesses in the world pay out a certain amount for labor, by shifting jobs from one location to another, they will pay out roughly the same. This means that those in a high wage location will lose income while those in a low wage location will gain. The benefits of globalization come as these costs equalize at a certain spot and the TOTAL economic output increases. This depends also on humans consuming ever more tomorrow than yesterday. So the bottom line is that globalization might benefit businesses, but can only benefit workers after a period of (downward) adjustment for the workers in middle class societies.
One (perhaps) unintended effect of globalization is the decreasing competitiveness of US businesses that carry health care costs on their corporate balance sheets. In most parts of the industrialized world, health care is nationalized. This means that the expense for health care is born by the nation and not by the business. When Toyota prices its autos, that price does not include a charge for health care for its workers. When GM prices its autos, hefty amount of the price tag is for that health care. If the US modified its health care system to match that of the other industrialized nations, those costs would be balanced out and Toyota and Chevy could compete on quality and product.
The United States certainly deserves better than what it has today. We spend more than any other nation on health care, and yet come in behind thirty other nations in the quality of care and in life expectancy, health indicators and other statistical measures. How many of us can even name thirty other countries? For the highest price tag, don’t we deserve the best health care in the world? It is what we demand of our military (for which we pay more than the rest of the world COMBINED.) Is our health not worth it.
The current interaction on health care could not be referred to as a debate, given the vociferous opposition to change driven by the misleading propaganda of the corporations bent on maintaining their profits at the expense of the health of Americans.
