On Fighting Corruption

by St. Alfonzo

I was thinking about our country and our propensity to export our values around the world.  I suppose this is a good thing, at least it seems to be on the surface, but lately I find myself wondering exactly what those values might be.

I regularly see articles and reports about U.S. government efforts to combat corruption, promote democracy, and achieve peace around the world.  Noble values all.  So as I sit here bursting with curiosity, let me do a little research.  In this case, I mean “little” because I want to take a stroll through the online dictionary to see what I come up with.

I think I will start with corruption, and leave the democracy and world peace for a later day, so let’s get started.

First, what exactly is corruption?  If you are like me, most of you probably haven’t defined it.  Instead we rely on the Justice Potter Stewart pornography description, “I know it if I see it.”  So let’s check "http://www.dictionary.com”, maybe not the best but always the easiest to remember.  For the noun corruption, we find nine definitions:  1) the act of corrupting or state of being corrupt; 2) moral perversion, depravity; 3) perversion of integrity; 4) corrupt or dishonest proceedings; 5) bribery; 6) debasement or alteration as of language or a text; 7) a debased form of a word; 8) putrefactive decay, rottenness; 9) any corrupting influence or agency.  I guess definitions 6 and 7 don’t apply here and 8 is probably not directly related (although I like it as a metaphor for the topic.)  Bribery seems pretty straightforward, giving money (or something else of value) in exchange for an action or behaviour not otherwise anticipated.  Definitions 2 and 3 highlight a commonality, perversion.  (I knew the pornography quote was here for a reason.)  In any case, we have a definition that implies leading one astray from some (moral) norms.

For the final three definitions (1, 4, and 9, for those of you keeping track), we have to return to the dictionary.  I find it troubling that words are routinely defined by themselves such as corruption means the act of corrupting.  So we find that corrupt is defined as “guilty of dishonest practices, lacking integrity, debased in character, depraved, wicked, evil.”  (NOTE:  I selected only the parts of the definition that were relevant to this rant.  If you don’t like it, tough.)  Now we have something to work with.  

Before we continue, I need to deal with the moral aspect of this topic.  Without getting too deep into the religious aspects of this topic, I want to point out that there are basically two types of morality:  individual and collective.  While interested in philosophies, I have not studies the finer points and there are probably better ways to describe this in some academic literature somewhere.  When I have time on my hands, maybe I will research the topic and provide proper citations.  Until then, let me explain what I mean.  Individual morality derives from the individuals desire to protect their own environment – property in the American vernacular.  In other words, this is how one behaves with himself and his immediate family and friends to the exclusion of those from outside the circle.  I think this concept is well understood in America, where it goes by the moniker of “individual freedom.”  Let those from outside the immediate circle interfere with these freedoms at their own peril!

The collective morality is perhaps better described as a culturally-driven set of rules applied to individuals by society.  I am thinking of this in terms of the individual’s obligations to his community.  Americans should also have a good sense of this type of morality since it has played a large role in the sacrifices individuals continue to make to defend the greatness of our nation.  However, Americans seem to forget that for these guidelines, culture (or society) play a role in defining the attributes of morality.  

I apologize to anyone who expected a greater discussion of these concepts here, but they were merely presented for informational purposes; an attempt to describe the framework from which we will proceed.

So, back to corruption.  Note that the definitions of corrupt include the words dishonest, debased, depraved, wicked, and evil.  These are, without a doubt, terms subject to moral interpretation.  Evil, like history, is written by the victors.  During World Wars I and II (and probably all the others), our enemies were characterized as evil by our government and our press, fabricating our shibboleths.  But our enemies’ enemies (we) were characterized in similar fashion by their own cultural outlets.  

So combating corruption is an effort based on our own societal norms and perhaps in conflict with those of our target audiences.  Is it bad that a politician in a developing country uses government resources to hand out cash to his constituents in exchange for support?  Probably so.  Is it worse that a politician in a developed country hands out benefits to corporations in exchange for support?  Hard to say, but I would argue that it is not inherently different.  

Let’s look at our own practices and discuss corruption.  Rezoning a plot of land to increase the value of a friend’s investment?  Using tax revenues to develop professional sports stadiums in support of a multi-billion dollar business venture?  Congressionally-mandated equipment purchases from defense industries despite the Pentagon’s assurances that they are not needed?  Using state funds for a private tryst to South America?  I am sure none of these happen here in the good, old USA.  If they did, wouldn’t we Americans be jumping and shouting and demanding justice be done?  

I have no argument with the idea of fighting corruption and think that it is a noble pursuit.  We, as America and Americans, need to stand up to corruption both at home and abroad.  But only when we devote the same efforts to putting our own house in order will the neighbors take us seriously when we offer to help them do the same.

Maybe I will tackle the issues of democracy and peace in the near future.  Stay tuned to find out.

© Hi-7 Ranch 2002-2018