While the IRS could be violating our civil rights, the ACLU is defending the wrong ones.
The recent revelations that certain employees of the non-profit section of the Internal Revenue Service “targeted the Tea Party1” caused a tsunami of chest-thumping rhetoric about the attacks on the freedoms of Americans. With congressional leaders, the President, and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) condemning 2 the act, maybe we should examine the issue.
The proliferation of groups claiming 501 (c) 4 tax exemptions and continued cuts to the federal budget mean that civil servants are struggling to keep up with an expanding work load. Within the IRS, as in other government agencies, the effort to identify fraud is paramount. By using keywords to identify areas that have exhibited a high level of fraud in the past (a sort of virtual profiling), these overworked bureaucrats were only looking for time-saving tactics to keep up with the expanding workload.
This does not justify the targeting of conservative groups, but it also does not signify the “politicization” of the bureaucracy. The ACLU’s criticism in defense of the First Amendment rights of Americans is well-intentioned, but a bit off of the mark. While these rights are important, the responsibilities are equally important. Everyone should have the right to his or her political belief, and should have the opportunity to promote it. However, qualifying for tax-exempt status is a technical issue that is not connected directly to these rights. It is the responsibility of Americans to comply with existing regulations, no matter how abhorrent, but the right of those same Americans to work to change those regulations. In the meantime, the responsible thing to do is to pay any taxes that are due.
Our founding fathers had no illusion that the power of money would corrupt our politics. But they staunchly defended the freedoms outlined in the Declaration of Independence. Importantly, one element of this freedom was the pride these leaders held in their convictions and the risks associated with it. The Declaration could have been published anonymously, guarding the identities of those who drafted it. John Hancock was the first to sign the document with the well-known flourish that led to the use of his name as a synonym for signature. According to the popular myth, he signed in this fashion so that “King George could read it without his spectacles.”
The freedom to express opinions is specifically reserved to the citizens of our country. With apologies to the ACLU, anonymity should not be. If you are proud of your beliefs, have the courage of your convictions to defend them. If you do not, then -- conservative and liberal alike -- you are merely promoting hate speech that you are too ashamed to acknowledge.
1 IRS Admits to Targeting Conservative Groups; http://news.yahoo.com/irs-admits-targeting-conservative-groups-224224521.html;_ylt=A2KJ2UgSCJJRgy4APcjQtDMD
2 Opinion: IRS abuses power in targeting tea party; http://www.cnn.com/2013/05/12/opinion/macleod-ball-irs-tea-party/
