Supreme Court (Non)Decision A Good Start

A recent Reuters article discussed the Supreme Court’s refusal of a case challenging the authority of the Environmental Protection Agency to regulate greenhouse gases.  Asarco LLC, the company challenging the new rules, claimed that enforcing the regulations "could cost companies $1.5 billion" to comply with regulations that were "needlessly stringent."  The EPA's position is that under the provisions of the "Clean Air Act," the limits are necessary to provide an "adequate margin of safety."

Like much of the discussion of climate change, the economic arguments presented are somewhat simplistic and misleading.  It is true that allowing companies a higher level of pollution improves corporate profitability (and attractiveness to shareholders), increases employment in that particular company or industry, and raises the level of economic activity associated with those industries.  Additionally, remediation of the damages caused can create corollary employment opportunities in cleaning up the pollution and treating illnesses it causes.

This is the cost of doing business, the engine that has driven the improving standards of living, at least in the developed world, for the past two centuries.  Less discussed, however, is that this is also an overdraft withdrawal from the global account of the economic commons.  The economy of the United States is predicated on the theory of free markets and this concept has demonstrated its utility worldwide.  On paper, at least,  each citizen has the opportunity, even the right, to access these public assets.  In reality, a system of tax exemptions (loopholes) and targeted investment incentives give some economic players an advantage even while burdening the general public with the cost of providing these advantages.  In effect, the “privatization” of the economic assets of the United States serves to divert funds from taxpayers and governments to corporations, shareholders, and consumers, a form of corporate welfare.  And with the export of our economic system since the middle of the twentieth century, much of the world experiences similar circumstances.  Of course, the balance is complicated by the fact that as individuals, we are often in more than one category, hence both profiting and losing from these loopholes.

Now, though, it could be time to rebalance the books.  This habit of using public economic goods for private profit has costs.  The question needs to be asked, who should pay these costs?  In the difficult economic environment facing the United States and much of the rest of the world, choices must be made.  National deficits are increasing and the voting public is increasingly uninterested in paying taxes for essential government services.  Continuing handouts to corporations, in effect subsidizing their profits, requires equal or greater government resources on the balance.  Arguing that regulations would bring an increase in costs is specious.  The costs are there.  The choice is between paying the cost of pollution (whether sulfur dioxide, carbon dioxide, or any of the number of pollutants necessary for our current consumerism) as we purchase gasoline, electricity, and iPhones or continuing the subsidies of corporate profits and consumers, spreading the costs across the entire society rather than charging the consumer.  

While this Supreme Court (non)decision is welcome, it is but one small victory for common sense.  We need to encourage more such rational decisions as well as a bigger discussion in the political sphere of our nation’s hopes and aspirations.

© Hi-7 Ranch 2002-2018