Avik Roy wrote in Forbes magazine in praise of a health care reform bill co-sponsored by Senators Tom Coburn, R-Okla., and Joe Lieberman- I-Conn. He called the effort "a significant proposal for Medicare reform." Not only is he mistaken, it would seem he is intentionally attempting to mislead his readers on not only the key challenges for Medicare, but also on the prospects for saving this key support for retirees, present and future.
Roy seems to base his analysis on three assumptions: entitlement spending must be slashed, fraud prevention aimed at beneficiaries will make a difference, and Americans work longer and retire with $170,000 in retirement benefits. Let's examine each one more closely.
Entitlement spending must be slashed. This is the call of many doomsayers out there and this call is made without any real assessment of either the validity of the claim or the impact of the action. First, these are entitlements because we have paid for them over the years. The irresponsibility of our elected representatives in giving away our national treasury to their Wall Street buddies should not affect us.
But, and this is the secret they want to keep from you, eliminating the benefits we have paid for will not balance the budget or even significantly lessen the national debt burden. Moreover, many economists think that the effects of slashing these programs will only serve to drag the economy further down, bringing on the call for more budget cuts.
Fraud costs taxpayers billions. This may be true, but let's put it in perspective. Estimates of Medicare fraud vary widely and none are very accurate, but the most reasonable assessment from the Congressional Budget Office is that 9 percent or less of Medicare spending is fraudulent.
And remember your history. Who perpetrates Medicare fraud? It is not granny heading in for her blood pressure checkup. It is the same corporations that overcharge for medical care in the first place. The reason for rising health care is that the corporations in charge of our health care raise the rates at a higher pace than our income rises and well ahead of inflation. Cost sharing with Medicare recipients will just shift their retirement income to the profit sheets of the same corporations.
Americans should work longer before enjoying their means-tested $170,000 per year. I don't know about you, but I don't expect a retirement like that. In fact, this amount suggested for means testing in the Lieberman-Coburn bill is earned by less than 3 percent of Americans. Where does that leave the rest of us? Well, results will vary according to your situation, but according to the Employee Benefit Research Institute, the average income for people ages 65 and older in 2008 was $29,214.
Using this figure, the average retired American would only be expected to pay out a little over one-fourth of her income annually. How does that $20,000 per year retirement look now? Another faulty assumption here is that Americans live longer. In some demographic categories, they do. However, those that work for a living doing the hard jobs, such as construction work or fire fighting, do not enjoy that advantage. On Wall Street, where salaries approach or exceed $1 million per day, life is indeed getting longer.
So, retirees making more than $300,000 per year will pick up more of the costs, and we will make sure that those old folks don't use too much medical service. Really? Mr. Roy, please, if you are going to pass yourself off as an expert in retirement matters, include the caveat: This advice is for our corporate sponsors. The average American should not try this at home.
