Revealing Campaign Secrets a Threat to America?

President Barack Obama's White House press secretary Jay Carney announced recently the White House intends to require federal contractors to declare political contributions.  Immediately, the outcry from Congress arose:  “No one should have to worry about whether their political support will determining their ability to get or keep a federal contract or keep their job,"  Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell said.

Thomas Jefferson

I hope we shall crush in its birth the aristocracy of our monied corporations which dare already to challenge our government to a trial by strength, and bid defiance to the laws of our country.

Let's be clear here, folks.  Your own contract supplying eggs to the local federal building cafeteria is not at risk.  This is aimed at the major federal contractors, the top five of whom, according to Federal Digest, collected $120,763,636,645 in 2010.  That amounts to about $350 each for every man woman and child in the U.S.  The number one recipient of contracts in both the military and civilian categories, Lockheed Martin, is also one of the top funders of political campaigns.  According to Open Secrets, the Lockheed Martin Political Action Committee raised $3.5 million for the 2010 election cycle.  

Elections depend on money and knowing where that money came from is important to understanding the message.  The Supreme Court ruled in 2010 that corporations have the same free speech rights as citizens, opening the door to new groups able to spend unlimited sums of money with no disclosure.  These groups, with no clear link to a candidate, influence our opinions without letting us know who is doing the talking.  Corporations are already required to file a limited report of political donations through PACs and candidates are also required to report where their money comes from.  Money spent through the new ‘527’ Committees and superPACs is not subject to these guidelines.  A better solution might be full disclosure of campaign spending.  In the current political climate, that solution is not likely, but this new guideline could open the door just a crack, letting a flicker of light in.  

Secrecy and democracy are always at odds but there are often justifiable reasons for government secrets.  We have secret courts authorizing secret wiretaps and investigating secret crimes.  Should this veil of secrecy extend to political campaigns as well?  At the outset, the founding fathers that crafted our Constitution were concerned about the ability of average citizens to influence the behavior of their government.  Our public interest is not served if our elected representatives can keep secret the benefactors who fund their campaign efforts.  The rationale for maintaining these secrets from the American public has not been satisfactorily explained.  So far, the criticism only addresses the supposed threats to John Q. Public, threats that, on the face of it, lack credibility.

 I, for one, see real benefit in being able to identify corporate money in political campaigns.  This goes double for corporate money that the taxpayers are providing to federal contractors.  This proposed directive to require federal contractors (i.e., corporations) to report political spending will likely be watered down so that it doesn't provide much more information than is available now.  Still, it is a step worth taking and is the least that the American public should demand of its office-seekers.

Allister Bull, “Obama seeks contractor campaign donation disclosure -- Yahoo! News,” Yahoo! News.

“Top 200 Federal Contractors (8/15/2010) -- GovExec.com,” Government Executive.com.

“Lockheed Martin| OpenSecrets,” Center for Responsive Politics.

Adam Liptak, “Supreme Court Blocks Ban on Corporate Political Spending -- NYTimes.com,” The New York Times.

© Hi-7 Ranch 2002-2018