The End of Capitalism?

by St. Alfonzo

The World is Ending! Capitalism as we know it is dying! The stock market is under attack and major Wall Street financial firms are failing. The pundits tell us that the entire system is in danger of collapsing while our President behaves like it is a curious event, barely engaged in the reality of the situation. Still, he seems to think that the same officials who engineered the crisis can save the situation by throwing vast sums of money at the same firms that got us in to this mess in the first place. And the American public, surprisingly enough, seemed to balk at being led like sheep into the solution recommended by these experts of questionable qualification.

Why the panic now? The indications have been visible in the collapse of the housing market for over eighteen months and warnings were issued (and ignored) for at least the past three years.

How did we get here? The Federal Reserve Bank, beginning during Alan Greenspan's tenure, encouraged free lending, over-heating the economy and raising the expectations of financiers and consumers alike. Home ownership rates rose from its sixty-year baseline of about 60 percent to 72 percent early this year (before the number of foreclosures began to impact the rate).

The current disruption in the housing and financial markets seems to me have its source among this group of new home owners only marginally capable of maintaining their investment, along with untold numbers of speculators who had hoped to flip a real estate deal for a profit even though their cash flow provided no margin of safety.

As performance among these risky loans began to falter, financial disaster struck a few companies that were overextended. The bundling and resale of these debts, encouraged by a loosening of government regulation and oversight over the past decade, was pervasive and many other companies chasing a return in the low-interest rate environment were entangled. Given the murk in the financial markets, banks will not loan to each other, for good reason. With questionable assets on the books and questionable cash flow assumptions, not only financial businesses but also many other businesses are suspect. It is no surprise. With these questions about my finances, no bank would loan money to me either.

Still, it would be unfair to blame the Bush Administration or Wall Street exclusively for this crisis. We asked for it. Americans are notorious for their unwillingness to save, sacrificing financial solvency in return for immediate gratification. This is a decades-old problem and one which does not appear to have an easy solution. The seduction of Americans by the siren song of easy credit is virtually complete and it will take years to wean ourselves from the addictive Mastercards.

Even with this dire social situation, the economic foundation of most Americans is sound, albeit threatened. So who do we need to bail out? We must save the "economy," we are told. However, the vast majority of homeowners have no problem making the sacrifices necessary to pay their bills on time and they continue to do so. The vast majority of businesses also operate on a cash flow basis and have no need for regular forays into the credit market to continue their operations. The bail out is intended to save those homeowners and businesses who were unwilling to settle for what they could afford in a house or too impatient to operate a business on a sound economic basis, preferring to leverage their investments in order to grow at a risky pace.

From the days of the dotcom market boom, exemplified by its "irrational exuberance" and fueled by policies that removed "risk" from the investment realm to the public one, Americans have been convinced that the market is always right and that there is no expectation of losing. Until now.

In the rush to save the economy, President Bush, abetted by a narrow-minded Congress, are proposing to borrow more money with which to purchase bad debt and "unfreeze" the credit markets. The beneficiaries of this policy are likely to be the very companies and individuals who made the original bad investments. It is difficult to divine any benefit for the vast majority of us who still sacrifice our immediate appetites in order to behave responsibly and pay our bills on time. And if the debt is bad now, why should it become better under government's ownership?

Many alternatives exist to this simple "throw money" solution. One of them is free market capitalism. If these businesses and individuals are unsuccessful, lets sacrifice them to the "Capitalist" system. Too big to fail? I don't recall that caveat in any explanation of free markets that our leaders have proposed.

Another way to approach this crisis would be to let those in trouble pay for the solution. A simple measure would be to re-instate the fee on stock transactions that was abolished in the 60's. With a three-tenths of one percent fee on stock and bond transactions, the U.S. Treasury could raise about $150 billion annually. While this does not reach the $700 billion the Administration would like to throw at the problem, it is a significant source of revenue that could be used to prime the credit pump. (After the crisis, it could also kick-start efforts to solve the Social Security and Medicare crises looming in the not-so-distant future.)

Of course, a combination of these three ideas, along with many of the others I have not covered, could provide a balanced approach to the crisis and leave the United States and the American taxpayers with some cash, some self-respect, and perhaps, some semblance of our capitalist system intact.

Kid's wooden arrows, Hollywood producers, auto race tracks! Are these the industries that are key to our national survival? This bailout could very well accelerate the end of capitalism and the return of our economy to cronyism.

Instead of rushing headlong into a half-baked solution, maybe we should consider a solution that supports every American citizen and business instead of only those that have failed.

© Hi-7 Ranch 2002-2018