by St. Alfonzo
I heard on the radio the other day that KFC is paying the City of Louisville, KY, a few thousand dollars to help fix potholes in their roads. While this sounds like a wonderfully altruistic act, it comes with strings attached. KFC, in exchange for the less than ten thousand dollars, gets the right to place advertising on the potholes. I can only imagine from the radio what these adds might look like. Maybe Colonel Sanders staring up from the blacktopped roadway? Maybe a chicken nugget? It boggles the mind.
I have reservations about the way advertising has permeated our society, from school bus seats to gas pumps. It is impossible to get away from ads anywhere one turns. I guess that is only to be expected of an economy that is driven by consumption regardless of need or ability to pay. And even with the economy under attack by mysterious beings from beyond our ability to understand (at least if we listen to the so-called experts, whether bankers or economists), this rampant push to consume continues. Remember former President George W. Bush’s infamous exhortation in the in the wake of the September 11 attacks: Keep shopping, that’ll show them! Even so, this concern is not the thing that made me write today.
The second part of the Louisville story involves PETI, an animal rights activist group. This group put up double the amount that KFC did in order to fill their own potholes. They merely wanted the same rights to put their message on said streets.
What was the response of the City of Louisville officials? Did they decide to look out for the interests of the voters and accept the money to fix more potholes? Of course not. While they decided that the offer from KFC’s corporate coffers was a good deal, the subsequent offer from a public interest group was deemed too controversial to pass their standards.
It reminds me of a day way back in the 1980s when a group decided to bid on grazing rights in a National Forest in Arizona. It was widely acknowledged that the Forest Service standards had led to severe overgrazing on the public ranges in that part of the state. Conservationists believed that taking cattle off the public lands would allow the ranges to rejuvenate themselves with little or no investment. Further, since the bidding on grazing rights was, in theory, open to all, participation in the bidding was merely an expression of a citizen’s freedoms.
The Forest Service turned down the highest bid, though, claiming that the “public good” was best served by continuing the grazing. Overturning the winning bids, they announced that the cattlemen whose livelihood depended upon the use of these public lands had to be defended. This without regard to the condition of the range, the financial benefits to be reaped from a higher bidder, and the benefit to the elk and antelope that were being pushed from their native ranges.
But again, this is not to rant against poor land management practices on the part of the federal agencies that hold the deed to our public lands and are tasked with managing them for the benefit of the American people. We can find many examples of these same practices, from Bureau of Land Management decisions to open roads on otherwise pristine wilderness to oil leases to the petroleum industry that are priced so low that the companies do not feel compelled follow up on their investments.
What concerns me today is the attitude of public officials, whether local or federal, that assumes that the business of government is business. What makes the BLM or the Forest Service believe that, after ignoring scientific findings, their decisions should take precedence over the expressed wishes of citizens willing to pay to play the game as designed? What makes the City of Louisville believe that ads for KFC on the city’s potholes is more of a benefit than ads against the mistreatment of animals by the same corporation?
We, the American public, must take an interest in the management of our common resources. The rates of political participation took an uptick this past year and it seems that many citizens have exhibited a renewed interest in our government. This is a good step, but citizenship does not end with casting the ballot every few years.
We, the American citizens, need to remain aware of the oddities of our over-developed bureaucracies and the accumulation of power in unusual places within our system. Ultimately, the U.S. Government is a government “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” And as in the past, it is up to Americans from all walks of life to commit themselves to defending the citizenry’s interests against those that would sacrifice them to expediency, laziness or greed.
Who can say why the Louisville news reminded me of events that happened decades ago? In the end, though, much of what is happening today is merely a repetition of the themes of the past. Unless we Americans understand this past and dedicate ourselves to keeping our democracy safe and healthy, we stand to lose much of what our forefathers passed on to us. Their commitment, their sacrifice, their vision could all be for naught if all Americans, who have enjoyed the benefits of our history, neglect to commit themselves to the obligations of an informed citizenry.
